Monday, March 17, 2008

The Narrative Paradigm in Nicki's Story of Racial Profiling

Racial profiling is a very serious issue in today’s society. Day in and day out, stories are told of how certain people in certain situations were discriminated against, or treated differently because of their race. As seen here, Nicki Sok tells a story of how he and his brother were enjoying a great day while traveling to a movie, and came across an act of racial profiling. Throughout this narrative, various examples and assumptions of the Narrative Paradigm are present.

The first of the Narrative Paradigm’s assumptions, humans are naturally storytellers, is shown from Nicki choosing to describe his unfortunate experience in the form of a story. This event being told in story form allows for a deeper impact within the minds of audience members in the process of Nicki conveying his emotions at the time. In terms of the Narrative Paradigm’s second and third assumptions, Nicki’s story holds up in the minds of his listeners because it is both believable and easy to relate to. Because of the knowledge his listeners had of previous racial profiling occurrences in the past, Nicki’s listeners were able to view his story as one that is both logical and credible, illustrating the second assumption of the Narrative Paradigm. The third assumption involves a narrative’s rationality being affected through its listener’s history, biography, culture, and character. Both history and biography allow for the persuasion of Nicki’s listeners through their recollection of historical events in which racial profiling existed, and their relation to a time when they too were bullied and humiliated. The material ultimately persuading Nicki’s listeners is that which is relevant to them personally, not that which works according to a set code of logic or persuasion.

When considering the fourth assumption of the Narrative Paradigm, the narrative’s rationality is dependent on the internal consistency and truth within it. Because Nicki’s story most likely strikes home with how listeners would’ve felt if put in that same situation, there is no question regarding the internal consistency and degree of truth present in his narrative. The paradigm’s fifth assumption involves the experiences of individuals within society as a set of selected stories, ultimately resulting in society living life in a continual process of re-creation. Nicki’s narrative follows this assumption through the idea of his listeners changing the way they think about racial profiling as a whole. From viewing how personally affected Nicki was by the events on that particular day, it would come as no surprise to me if his narrative’s impact on particular listeners was significant. As a whole, the story Nicki told about being racially profiled was one which demonstrated the various assumptions of the Narrative Paradigm successfully.

4 comments:

Dan Verello said...

This is a prime example of race division in America. Nicki delivers the story to his friend to get across the idea of racial discrimination, and as soon as he gets out of the car, they expreience even more prejudice for the color of their skin. The Narritive Paradigm is all about delivering an effictive story in a way which bolsters your argument, thesis, or opinion. This is a fine example of such an occurance. Had Nicki simply told his friend that there was a problem with racism and he was totally against it, it would have had nowhere near the impact in which it had with the story.

Yifeng Hu said...

In the third paragraph, you wrote "Because Nicki’s story most likely strikes home with how listeners would’ve felt if put in that same situation, there is no question regarding the internal consistency and degree of truth present in his narrative." That Nicki's story rings true to his audience exemplifies fidelity only. You need more analysis to illustrate internal consistency.

Jessica Mathelier said...

Nicki's story is filled with emotion. The Narrative Paradigm is shown by the telling the story of experiences instead of a generalized fact. We humans look for stories as a way of relating and making connections

Chanice_Truitt said...

This is an interesting way to portray the narrative paradigm. I like the fact that you used something that all of us has encountered at least once in our lives; racial profiling. It is very relatable and hits home for me. The way that Nicki tells the story, and the way that she incorporated the components of the narrative paradigm makes the story more valid.